HOME ◼︎ DHAMMA ◼︎ WRITING ◼︎ TOPICS ◼︎ STUDY GUIDES ◼︎ SUTTAS ◼︎ PALI STUDY ◼︎RESOURCES
The Story of the Two Arrows
Rebecca Fox Stoddard
August 2025
The Buddha once described life’s pains as being struck by an arrow. That first arrow is the unavoidable pain of being human — the aches, losses, disappointments, and challenges that touch everyone. But most of us, without realizing it, pick up a bow and shoot ourselves with a second arrow.
That second arrow is everything the mind adds after the first. It’s the stories, judgments, and fears that turn pain into suffering.
It happens so fast we rarely notice it. The first arrow — pain — arrives and is followed almost instantly by a cascade of thoughts: “Why me?” “This always happens.” “I can’t handle this.” The second arrow is this inner commentary, and it often wounds us far more deeply than the first.
The First Arrow: Pain That Comes With Life
The first arrow is the pain that can’t be avoided. Bodies get injured. Relationships change. We lose people we love. These moments hurt, no matter how wise or kind or experienced we are.
A sprained ankle. A friend forgetting your birthday. A sudden job loss. These are part of life’s landscape. The Buddha himself experienced illness, injury, and the gradual decline of aging. The difference between a mind in turmoil and a mind at peace is not whether pain happens, but what happens next.
Pain is unavoidable. Suffering is not.
The Second Arrow: The Stories We Tell
The second arrow begins with the mind’s reaction. It’s what we tell ourselves after the first arrow strikes.
A headache becomes:
- “I’ll never get everything done.”
- “Something must be seriously wrong.”
A harsh word becomes:
- “They don’t care about me.”
- “I must have done something wrong.”
In a moment, pain is no longer just pain — it’s a whole narrative about our worth, our future, and our place in the world. We rehearse past injuries, imagine worst‑case scenarios, and cast ourselves as victim or failure.
The second arrow is optional, but it rarely feels that way because it happens so quickly.
Why We Keep Shooting
If the second arrow causes so much suffering, why do we keep firing it?
Partly because we don’t recognize it as separate from the first arrow. We feel the pain and immediately believe the story that follows. The space between sensation and reaction is so brief we think they’re the same thing.
We also tend to believe our thoughts are accurate reflections of reality. When the mind says, “I’m not safe” or “They’ve never cared,” it feels like truth, not just a passing interpretation.
And often, the second arrow is a habit we’ve been practicing for years. We react to discomfort with blame, worry, or self‑criticism without realizing we’re adding to the pain.
How to Set the Bow Down
The second arrow loses its power when we can see it for what it is — an extra wound we don’t have to inflict.
The first step is noticing. When something painful happens, pause. Ask yourself:
- Is this the pain itself, or am I already adding to it?
- What is the raw sensation here, without my story about it?
If you can stay with the direct experience — the tightness in the chest, the throbbing in the knee, the hollow in the stomach — without adding judgments or forecasts, you’ve already spared yourself the second arrow.
This isn’t about pretending pain isn’t there. It’s about meeting it without multiplying it.
Finding the Gap
Between the first arrow and the second is a gap — a moment, however small, when we can choose. We don’t control whether the first arrow strikes, but in that pause before reaction, we can decide whether to reach for the bow.
At first, that gap might seem impossible to find. But it grows with practice. You might notice it while meditating, when an itch arises and you have the choice to scratch it or simply observe it. Or in daily life, when someone cuts you off in traffic and you feel the spark of anger — and can decide whether to fan it into a blaze.
The gap is the doorway to freedom.
Living Without the Second Arrow
This teaching doesn’t mean ignoring pain or forcing yourself to “stay positive.” It means seeing the difference between what hurts and what we add to the hurt.
A life without the second arrow is still a life with challenges. You still make difficult phone calls, recover from illnesses, and grieve losses. But you meet these moments without doubling the pain with your own hand.
Imagine a disagreement with a close friend. The first arrow is the sting of their words. Without awareness, you might add the second arrow: rehearsing the conversation in your head, replaying their tone, imagining future arguments. But if you meet that first arrow without adding the second, you can respond calmly, address what matters, and keep the relationship intact.
Or think of waiting for medical test results. The first arrow is the discomfort of uncertainty. The second arrow is the mind’s stream of worst‑case scenarios. Choosing not to fire that second arrow doesn’t make the waiting pleasant — but it keeps you from living through imagined disasters before anything has even happened.
Practicing in Daily Life
You can begin to work with the second arrow in small, ordinary moments:
- Physical discomfort: Notice the raw sensations without making them a problem to solve immediately.
- Minor inconveniences: When plans change, see if you can meet it with flexibility instead of irritation.
- Emotional triggers: When someone says something that stings, pause before you respond — and notice what’s actually happening inside you.
The more you practice in small situations, the more skill you have for bigger ones.
Common Misunderstandings
- “If I don’t fire the second arrow, I’m just suppressing my feelings.”
- “If I practice this, I’ll become indifferent.”
Not firing the second arrow doesn’t mean ignoring pain — it means feeling it fully without adding unnecessary suffering.
In reality, this practice often makes people more compassionate, because they’re not overwhelmed by their own reactivity. They have space to care for themselves and others.
A Life with Fewer Arrows
Every time you notice the second arrow and choose not to fire it, you step into a quieter, steadier way of being. You still feel the ups and downs of life, but you’re no longer hostage to the mind’s automatic reactions.
This practice is simple to understand but lifelong to master. And it’s available in every moment. The next time pain appears — physical or emotional — pause. Feel the first arrow fully. See if you can set the bow down before the second one flies.
Glossary: Terms from the Second Arrow Teaching
Arrow metaphor — A teaching image used by the Buddha in the Sallatha Sutta (SN 36.6). The first arrow represents unavoidable pain. The second arrow represents the mental suffering we add through our reactions.
Dukkha — Often translated as “suffering,” but also meaning dissatisfaction, stress, or unease. It refers to the fundamental unsatisfactoriness of conditioned life. Central to the First Noble Truth (SN 56.11).
Vedanā — Feeling tone: the immediate experience of something as pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral. Distinct from emotion. Discussed in the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10 / DN 22).
Papañca — Mental proliferation; the tendency of the mind to elaborate on experience, creating complex stories and reactions. Mentioned in the Madhupiṇḍika Sutta (MN 18).
Avijjā — Ignorance or not-seeing; the fundamental misunderstanding of reality as permanent, satisfactory, and personal. The first link in Dependent Origination (SN 12.1).
Taṇhā — Craving or thirst; the strong desire for pleasant experiences and the urge to avoid unpleasant ones. The cause of suffering in the Second Noble Truth (SN 56.11).
Paṭiccasamuppāda — Dependent Origination; the process by which suffering arises, showing how contact leads to feeling, craving, clinging, and becoming (SN 12.1).
Satipaṭṭhāna — The Four Foundations of Mindfulness: mindfulness of body, feelings, mind, and mental qualities. A core practice for freeing the mind from suffering (MN 10 / DN 22).
Ekasalla — “One arrow”; the phrase used in the Sallatha Sutta to describe the experience of the noble disciple, who feels only the first arrow of pain, not the second arrow of suffering.
Related Articles
A beginner-friendly introduction to Buddhism. This essay offers a clear, exploration of what Buddhism is—and what it isn’t—through the life of the Buddha, the Four Noble Truths, and the path of practice. No jargon, no mysticism—just a human invitation to clarity, freedom, and direct experience.
The Four Noble Truths move from recognizing life’s unease, to seeing its cause, to the possibility of release, and the Noble Eightfold Path that leads there.
A reflection on Maylie Scott’s teaching that “nothing is out of place,” exploring how loneliness can be met with mindful presence and compassion.
When attention softens, the forest responds. Birds, breath, and baseline become a mirror—not of self, but of tone, pressure, and the wake of thought.
The Noble Eightfold Path begins with the recognition of dukkha—the universal tension at the heart of conditioned life. This chapter explores that recognition as the spark for spiritual practice.
Related Resources
Would Love to Hear From You!
Topics
Related Writing